Profilbild Ludmila Ceban
Ludmila Ceban 5 april / 2019

Elections aside, more focus on the rule of law needed in Ukraine

During the presidential elections in Ukraine on March 31, 2 690 violations of the electoral law were reported to the police. The Central Electoral Commission received over 130 complaints. But the appeals, complaints and their effectiveness haven’t necessarily made the headlines in the view of the actual election results.

The type of complaints, however, coupled with over 80 investigations on vote-buying, questionable campaign financing, and the manipulation of administrative resources at the national and local level, are highlighted in the preliminary findings of the OSCE/ODIHR election observation mission.

If elections can be considered a reflection of good governance and efficiency of the public administration, it is relevant to look deeper into the actual effectiveness of the complaints. Or is the right to effective legal remedy, guaranteed by the election law, just one example of a sound legal framework on paper?

Elections aside, Ukraine has comprehensive laws protecting citizens’ rights to appeal. Yet a general skepticism on the effectiveness of appeal and dispute resolution procedures persists. As a participant in one of the focus group discussions, held within the framework of the FBA rule of law project in Ukraine, phrased it:

I do not want to appeal anything. This is red tape…no one has ever won in court with the state. Because the mechanism is such that it kind of gives with one hand, and takes away with the other. It is impossible to sue the state. One doesn’t have enough money.


As a fundamental principle of the rule of law, the right to appeal allows individuals to seek redress against administrative decisions. This can be done through internal reviews, ordinary courts or specialised administrative courts. It also ensures that public agencies communicate and explain the reasons for their decisions. Ensuring effective procedures and mechanisms for appeal are therefore essential to a rule of law based system of governance.

Over the past four years FBA, enabled by financial support from the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida), has been working with Ukrainian authorities in assessing rule of law principles at the local level. While positive examples exist, more needs to be done to ensure the legal certainty, transparency and effectiveness of procedures. It remains to be seen whether the final election results on April 21 will translate into meaningful change for people’s everyday lives in Ukraine.

av Ludmila Ceban
Profilbild Ludmila Ceban

Skrivet av Ludmila Ceban

Ludmila arbetar för närvarande med projektet Local Self-Government and the Rule of Law in Ukraine. Hon är placerad på FBA:s program för rättsstatsuppbyggnad och utbildad i statsvetenskap och Europastudier. Ludmila intresserar sig främst för policyutveckling, rättsstatsuppbyggnad i konflikt- och post-konfliktländer och reformprocesser i Östeuropa.

Fler inlägg av Ludmila Ceban

Escalation in Ukraine

18 december, 2018

No one could have missed the recent escalated Russian aggression against Ukraine. While the daily casualties in Donbas (reportedly over 1300 ceasefire violations per day) tend to receive less media coverage, the declared martial law covering ten regions of Ukraine came as a reality check of sorts. Possible limitations on individual rights and freedoms remain […]

Conflict resources and the rule of law

18 maj, 2018

Over 40 per cent of all intrastate conflicts have a link to natural resources and, while it is not new evidence as such, less than a quarter of peace negotiations actually aim to resolve conflicts by addressing resource management mechanisms. By the same token, links to natural resources are rarely included in the design of […]

Technical problems, political fixes: assessing rule of law in local governance in Ukraine

12 september, 2017

I take public sector reform challenges in the post-Soviet space quite personally, with many first-hand Kafkaesque experiences from growing up in the ‘east’. So when the opportunity came about to work for the FBA on improving service delivery from a rights-based perspective in Ukraine, I struggled to think of alternatives to the complicated procedures people […]

Fler inlägg

Senaste inläggen

Alla inlägg
Profilbild Klara Grenhagen
Klara Grenhagen 4 april / 2024

Moçambique – extremism och våldets svårlösta ekvation

Våldet eskalerar i norra Moçambique. Under årets två första månader skördades nästan lika många dödsoffer som under hela fjolåret. Halshuggningar, brända byar, långa följen av flyende människor och svarta IS-flaggor som vajar i övertagna områden. Efter sju år av våldsamma attacker fortsätter ett komplext konfliktsystem att veckla ut sig, med konsekvenser för hela regionen. Vi […]